
I’m no expert on how decisions get made when it comes to turning books into movies. But, I’m enjoying writing about it. Amazon Prime has been pushing The Summer I Turned Pretty series hard. I refused to watch until I read (listened) to Book 1 and that Libby wait was a long one. I ultimately decided to wait because I thought the Prime series adaptation would be good for another comparison review.
To be honest I didn’t really love the book – and I’m a fan of Jenny Han. I’ve read all of the P.S. I Love You series (the last one made me cry) & thoroughly enjoyed the movie series as well. However, The Summer I Turned Pretty was giving me lazy beach read. I had no idea how this would translate to the silver screen. As I began to watch the series I noticed A LOT of differences and I realized that they had to add so much to make it more dramatic – there simply was no other way.
The love triangle seemed childish in the books – but then again this is a young adult series. Unlike the critiques on my last pick on instagram (The Perfect Find) I found myself agreeing with the critiques for this adaption. There is no team Jeremiah or team Conrad. We basically are anti-Belly at this point (I hate being anti a female main character).
I listened to the book while doing chores and driving. I typically listen to mystery thrillers and that may have contributed to why I found myself getting tired while listening and just lacking overall excitement. My attention was not exactly grabbed by the storyline. I don’t even know that it could be a called a slow-burn romance. It was a flickering of light here and there, barely there smoke signals. The most emotional aspect of course was learning of Susannah’s fate. The moment that I did get excited – Belly getting picked up in secret, came at the very end of the book. I didn’t know if I should be let down or just acknowledge the brilliant cliffhanger.
Alternatively, the show is giving constant drama. At first I was confused by the debutante story line but it became a great tool for demonstrating the tension between all the different relationships such as between Belly and her mom, Belly and the girls on Cousin’s beach, and of course Susannah’s boys (Conrad and Jeremiah). I found myself more invested in the storyline as I wondered who would be Belly’s date to the debutante ball? How long would Belly actually be able to conceal her feelings or figure out her feelings enough to make a decision? I loved seeing the setting of Cousin’s Beach come alive.
This is a rare instance in which I think the show adaptation is better than the book and added depth to the story. I’ve been so intrigued by the Prime tv story live that I’ve moved on to despite the fact that I’m once again on a lengthy waiting list for It’s Not Summer Without You (Book 2 of the Series). I usually hate not being able to binge a show and streaming sites not releasing all episodes at once. Admittedly, I have been waiting on baited breath for every new episode.






