Black Girl in Paris | Book Review by Sam

 

About:

Black Girl in Paris by Shay Youngblood is a coming of age novel. After reading about the author’s life this novel felt like perhaps a dramatized version of her life. The main character (Eden), like the author, is a writer, who moves to Paris to follow her creative dreams and like the author takes on odd jobs to make a living until she can hopefully make it big as a writer. We follow as Eden goes through the harsh realities of being in what’s supposed to be the Black creative mecca.

Review:

The backdrop of Black Girl in Paris by Shay Youngblood is Paris in the mid-1980s. When we are introduced to Eden, she seems like a naive but hopeful 20-something year old. She moves to Paris because all the great Black artists of the Harlem Renaissance that she looks up to moved there to thrive creatively. However, she moves to Paris with no money at all. A young Black Parisian girl takes her under her wing and she is saved momentarily.

From there Eden becomes a nanny and then engages in a few other questionable activities to make money. You can feel her desperation to live and eat and simply take care of herself through the pages. Eden meets several interesting characters throughout her time in Paris – and not all of them mean her well. She will not always navigate being introduced to these characters in the smartest way but she does always learn a lesson and shares it with us. You may read and want Eden to win as a fellow creative, you may want to see a dream realized. But internally you may also be screaming at her “Girl, does this make sense?” 

In true artist form you will read about Eden seemingly to fall in love multiple times for different reasons with men, women, and I would go so far as to say queer persons although the author does not specifically identify them as such. The author highlights love in several forms, the romantic sense as well as the community sense. The importance of having a home away from home – in a place, a person, a community is evident. It is often the life force that helps you keep going. In the variety of characters that we learn about you may find someone that is familiar to you – I know this was true for me as someone who lived abroad and lived in 3 different cities throughout my 20s.  

The author made stylistic choices to continue to bring to the forefront that this is Paris in the 80s and racism and terrorism is very much alive – no matter what the James Baldwins and the Josephine Bakers want you to believe about Paris, it is not perfect. In the end the harder Eden tries the more she seems to be set back, it is not until she finally lets go of all expectations that her dreams seem to come together. 

Read this story to get a healthy dose of what it means to be an artist with a mix of reality and romance.

 

A Song Below Water | Book Review by Felicia

 

About:

This book is all about Black Girl Magic. Two really close friends are living in a world that despises and discriminates against Sirens. As young black girls growing up one must discover a way to find her voice and the other needs to discover who is her authentic self. Along the way they must deal with the traumatic current events that tell black girls they do not matter.

Review:

A Song Below Water  Review: 

Ranking: 2 Stars for this one. It was rough to get through this book. I almost didn’t want to finish it at all. The concept of the book is wonderful. It involves the essence of Black girl magic mixed with social justice. But, the execution fell through. In the end, the book felt like it was doing too much. 

This was a short and impactful read. The best aspect of the book was the main characters’ love and support for each other. I love to see young Black girls who are unified and well connected. I was rooting for the main characters to discover their confidence and find a way to be their true selves. However, that is all the only thing I  loved about this book. There were too many elements to this book that made the writing and story go all over the place which caused me to not enjoy reading this novel. As a fantasy novel I felt very overwhelmed and confused by the magic system in this world. I am left with many questions but without any desire to discover the answers. I felt tired and over the concept of the book by the end. Unfortunately, I was not enthralled by the overall storyline or writing. 

Podcast 13 Show Notes

 For episode 13 we read Bethany Morrow’s A Song Below Water

About the Author

Bethan C. Morrow is a California native, she graduated from University of California with a Bachelor’s in Sociology. Morrow is an accomplished writer with several other books, and the sequel to A Song Below has been released, and is titled A Chorus Rises

Book Look

A beautiful and eye-catching book cover. The book cover played into the fantastical and fun theme the sisters were looking to read around Halloween.

Bookmark

  • “My voice is power. Awaken” p. 277
  • “I’m talking about things like illumination and warmth – things that help me see more clearly and feel more comfortable in my own skin and he’d talk about how those are things that bring “growth” p. 30

POV

Sam and Felicia enjoyed the overarching theme of Black women as magic in A Song Below. Although a fantasy novel, there are common themes that an everyday Black girl would identify with such as natural hair and sisterhood.

Deep Dive

In A Song Below Water, mythical creatures are known to the human world. However, sirens are considered dangerous and they are exclusively Black women. There is something mysterious going on in the lives of Tavia and Effie. Tavia is realizing her true power as a Siren. Effie is learning about the truth of her mythical powers. Even in a mythical world racism is alive and well and the girls will have to learn who is truly on their side and recognize they can accomplish far more than they think.   Ultimately the sisters felt like something was missing and there wasn’t enough for them to go off of to really fall in love with the story.